Pages

Wednesday, March 15, 2017

MARCH 2017 BOOKERS MINUTES & MUSINGS, The All-Girl Filling Station’s Last Reunion by Fannie Flagg

 “That blouse was cut so low you could see her breakfast.” A Southernism

16 “blue bloods” arrived at the Magee’s Saint Andrews “filling station” armed with books to donate to the Pinnacle Club Lending Library and an assortment of luck of the Irish items for Jane Freer’s “green” project…delivered to her door, welcomed, and appreciated by her and Gary! Mission accomplished. The report earlier was Linda Hoff had a setback, but as of this writing, she is back home and doing much better. Bookers send well wishes and hopes she will be able to join us again soon. Many thanks to Bonnie Magee and Rosemary Farmer for setting the stage for this month’s selection…from the sign on the door to the bird feed and feeder to the model airplane, to Rosemary dressed in “filling station” attire!

Barbara Creach offered a summary of this quirky, wise, witty, warm-hearted novel that showed up “wearing a big smile and bright clothes” set in the historic little town of Point Clear, Alabama. The story opens just as fifty-nine year old Mrs. Sookie Poole has married off the last of her daughters in elaborate theme weddings and is looking forward to her golden years with her dentist husband, Earle. Her mother, Lenore nicknamed “Winged Victory,” was “terribly energetic and startlingly beautiful at age 88” lived two houses away and insisted Sookie embrace the traditions of every Southern lady, real pearls and a full set of silver – Francis the First, of course. Then the phone rings and a man says, “You are not who you think you are.” Sookie is not a “belle” after all…Lenore did not writhe in pain for forty-eight hours to give her life. She was adopted and a child of a Catholic Polish unwed mother with an unpronounceable last name.” Sookie’s search for answers leads us on a journey back to World War II where we learn of a little known piece of history about the WASP’s…Women Airforce Service Pilots who ferried military planes from their factory of origin to their point of departure for various fronts. The ending is full of discovery and acceptance with the characters receiving their fair share of “happiness bombs.” Many thanks to Barbara for an excellent review and discussion…the selection delivering as hoped, a mini-panacea designed to lift spirits.

The WASP’s story, not recognized officially for thirty-five years as their service records were sealed and classified, was of particular interest to our group as much like the “hidden figures” in our space program, these women paved the way for female roles on the largest of stages. We talked about the patriotism during World War II…everyone’s mindset was what do we need to do to win this war and get our men back home and the sacrifices every American made to facilitate that effort. Some suggested the difference beginning with Viet Nam and into today’s conflicts, is that the wars are not seen as “winnable” as often happens once we’ve sacrificed lives and leave the country, it reverts to “business as usual.” We offered some of our own “motherly wisdoms” to add to Lenore’s, “make sure your luggage matches,” like always wear clean underwear in case you get in an accident (did you ever think that if you were in an accident, those clean underwear might get soiled…just saying. Never ever wear white because it will make your butt look big…don’t ever rub your eyes…pearls and proper English will take you anywhere you want to go…sit up straight…if you can’t say something nice don’t say anything at all…always check the lint trap in the dryer…don’t air your dirty laundry. The more we talked the more we remembered some of the things our ancestors used to say…like you “know you’re a blue blood.” Do you know why the Royals are referred to as blue blooded? Nor did I…here’s the scoop. Great Grandma put a silver dollar in the milk to keep it from spoiling as it sat on the back porch in the summertime. Silver is a powerful, natural antibiotic that has been used for thousands of years. Kings, emperors, sultans and their families ate from silver plates, drank from silver cups, used….drum roll…Francis the First (or a similar pattern,) and they stored their food in silver containers. Silver slightly rubbed off and mixed in with their food…the Royals’ skin had a blue tint due to the accumulation of minute traces of pure metallic silver….history lesson over. We did discover that no matter whether you grew up north or south of the Mason-Dixon Line, etiquette, good manners, and family tradition carries you a long way in life.

On the Business side
The Shack, William P., Young’s debut novelBookers’ book, November 2008, is now a movie. It’s a wonderfully written and poignant book beginning with a man in the depths of “the great sadness”…a broken believer struggling to bury the burden of guilt after his youngest daughter is kidnapped and presumed murdered. Keep up with the author at wpy@wmpaulyoung.com.

We asked anyone with a copy of Left Neglected to donate their copy to MN to assist her brother in his seminar on the subject. She would make a donation to the PWC as reimbursement. Bonnie reminded us we supplied Diane Ewing with this book as she struggled with similar symptoms from her illness. However, if you have a copy, I’ll make sure MN gets it.
We threw out the idea of dedicating next year Bookers’ (if I’m invited to return to the helm by the new PWC President) to a theme, memoirs, non-fiction, historical fiction, mysteries, bestsellers…the consensus…variety wins again!

The books for the Pinnacle Club Lending Library will be delivered upon completion of the downstairs construction. They are stored at Bonnie Magee’s home for now. Daryl suggested asking Dee Dee to include a notice in the newsletter about the library, as most residents don’t know about its existence.
 
Janet Noblitt recommended Hillbilly Elegy by J.D. Vance. It’s a memoir written by a former marine and Yale Law School graduate…a powerful account of growing up in a poor Rust Belt town. It’s a personal analysis of a culture in crisis – that of white working-class Americans. He tells the true story of what a social, regional, and class decline feels like when you were born with it hung around your neck.
Others you might enjoy reading are as follows:
The Tennis Partner, memoir by Dr. Abraham Verghese, the author of Cutting for Stone. With his marriage unraveling, he relocates to El Paso where he meets a medical student recovering from drug addiction and the two men begin a tennis ritual that allows them to shed their inhibitions and find security in the sport they love and with each other.
Tribe by Sebastian Junger (only 192 pages).Decades before the American Revolution, Benjamin Franklin lamented that English settlers were constantly fleeing over to the Indians-but Indians almost never did the same. Tribal society has been exerting an almost gravitational pull on Westerners for hundreds of years, and the reason lies deep in our evolutionary past as a communal species. The most recent example of that attraction is combat veterans who come home to find themselves missing the incredibly intimate bonds of platoon life. The loss of closeness that comes at the end of deployment may explain the high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder suffered by military veterans today. Combining history, psychology, and anthropology, Tribe explores what we can learn from tribal societies about loyalty, belonging, and the eternal human quest for meaning.
Lincoln in the Bardo, George Saunders new novel, a moving and original father-son story featuring Abraham Lincoln, as well as an unforgettable cast of supporting characters, living and dead, historical and invented. February 1862. The Civil War is less than one year old. The fighting has begun in earnest, and the nation has begun to realize it is in for a long, bloody struggle. Meanwhile, President Lincoln’s beloved eleven-year-old son, Willie, lies upstairs in the White House, gravely ill. In a matter of days, despite predictions of a recovery, Willie dies and is laid to rest in a Georgetown cemetery. “My poor boy, he was too good for this earth,” the President says at the time. “God has called him home.” Newspapers report that a grief-stricken Lincoln returns, alone, to the crypt several times to hold his boy’s body. The negatives I’ve heard are that it is confusing and written in very unconventional style.

Possible Summer Reads:
We are considering American’s First Daughter by Stephanie Dray and Laura Kamoie as our summer read. (600 pages). It’s an historical fiction telling of Thomas Jefferson’s eldest daughter, Martha “Patsy” Jefferson Randolph, the woman who kept the secrets of our most enigmatic founding father. She became the “first lady” when her mother died and at fifteen learned about her father’s troubling liaison with Sally Hemings, a slave girl her own age.
Beartown, by Fredrik Backman, bestselling author of A Man Called Ove returns with a dazzling, profound novel about a small town with a big dream—and the price required to make it come true. People say Beartown is finished. A tiny community nestled deep in the forest is slowly losing ground to the ever-encroaching trees. But down by the lake stands an old ice rink, built generations ago by the working men who founded this town. And in that ice rink is the reason people in Beartown believe tomorrow will be better than today. Their junior ice hockey team is about to compete in the national semi-finals, and they actually have a chance at winning. All the hopes and dreams of this place now rest on the shoulders of a handful of teenage boys. Set to release April 25th.

Elizabeth Strout’s latest, Anything Is Possible is set to release April 25th. It’s written in the same vein as Olive Kitteridge, a series of linked short stories exploring the whole range of human emotion through the intimate dramas of people struggling to understand themselves and others. She’s taken the characters from My Name Is Lucy Barton, featuring the return of Lucy to her hometown after a seventeen-year absence.

FYI, we had talked about Life in a Box being our summer read. Unfortunately, its status is a bit dicey right now, as my publisher has been hospitalized. The book is in her hands for “final” edits. I’m hopeful the release date will still be May, but I’m not certain so looking at a backup plan for summer reading. Thanks for caring!!!! In the meantime, I’ve set up a website with some information on the book, the characters, motivations, etc…check it out and let me know what you think: www.jodeeneathery.com.

                                     COLOR CODING SYSTEM
                                     WHITE:         LIGHT READ
                                     PINK:             MODERATELY CHALLENGING
                                     RED:              CHALLENGING
April 11th:                              The Girl Who Wrote In Silk, by Kelli Estes, debut
                                                PINK
                                                The protagonist discovers an elaborately stitched piece of fabric hidden in her deceased aunt’s island estate revealing a connection with a young Chinese girl mysteriously driven from her home a century before.
Reviewer: Pat Faherty
                                                Home of Rokhshie Malone
May 2nd                                  Earlier date due to travel conflict
                                                Orphan # 8 by Kim van Alkemade
                                                RED
                                                Reviewer: Patty Evans
                                                Wine & Cheese evening meeting, 6:00 p.m.
Home of Melanie Prebis.
                                                Bonnie Magee, Food Czar

Summer Read:                        To be determined

                                                   “Don’t let anyone put dill in your pickle!”
Happy Reading,

JoDee

Saturday, February 18, 2017

FEBRUARY 2017 BOOKERS MINUTES & MUSINGS, Miss Jane by Brad Watson

      
                   “A little girl, I believe”
   Love does not exist in gazing at each other, but in looking outward in the same direction.     
                        Antoine de Saint-Exupery

22 umbrella-ed Bookers braved the cold wind and rain to Jean Alexander’s home on Valentine’s Day. This day is associated with love, hearts, roses, cupid, chocolate, and lace. Ironically, the history of the day relates to this month’s book selection. As the legend goes, February 14 was referred to by the Romans as the fertility festival, the day birds began mating. How about that for matching the day with the book….pure luck!

A warm welcome to Ann Ireland, joining us for the first time, and it was wonderful seeing Melba back again. We hope both will become regular fixtures at Bookers. Melba thanked everyone for their prayers, support and blood donations during their daughter’s illness seven years ago. A college fund was set up at that time for their granddaughter through the generosity of the community. Julia has now graduated from high school and will be the recipient of this outpouring of love as she embarks on the next chapter of her life. Pat Faherty’s husband, Greg, is now home and recovering from his knee replacement, heart attack, and pneumonia! They also appreciate all our support in their time of need. Jane Freer was so moved by our “hat” campaign last month and we know she will enjoy her basket of Valentine wishes. Many thanks to MN for making these handmade treasures! Jane’s husband, Gary, is home now after suffering a slight stroke on Sunday and is doing well. Our special community rallies through heartbreak until the heartwarming takes its place.

Jean Alexander in the typical flair we’ve come to expect, dressed in the role of sixty-seven year old Miss Jane Chisolm, giving her review from a rocking chair accompanied by a jar of apple brandy and cigarettes. Rocking away in character she talked about the letter she received from John Hopkins offering to “fix” her condition…about the anger of the timing and the tears of frustration. She had spent a lifetime living with her condition…a lifetime of disguising her condition…a lifetime of accepting the circumstances dictated by her condition. Why now?

Jane’s rare urological condition affected every character in the book. Her mother Ida said Jane’s “soul was corrupt at birth” coming in a sinful way, Ida not able to remember anything about the conception. Her father, Sylvester, blamed himself – he was ten years older than his wife, and she was too old to have another child and he was “too drunk and too cheap to pay two dollars for a whore.” By the time Grace was ten, she was determined to leave the farm. She resented being Jane’s surrogate mother, but confessed, “I have to love something.” In order to keep Elijah and Jane from inevitable heartbreak, her family separated them…love bloomed and died before she had to reveal her secret. Dr. Thompson, Jane’s friend, confidant, mentor, and father figure took a special interest in the baby he welcomed into the world. She was the child he never had, wanting desperately to find a way for her to be “normal.”

Jane’s family life mirrored a character in a silent movie. Stern looks answered questions. Muttering replaced conversation. Innuendo masked truths. All around her though, the simplicity of creation in its most natural form was before her eyes…the erotic world of nature on display for her to learn about reproduction…something she would never experience. .She saw in herself, a beauty not unlike the peacocks – oddly beautiful – making her feel less alone in the world…less strange. The Greeks believed physical love was the lowest form of love. True love was akin to divine love. The Catholic religion views the peacock as a sign of resurrection, renewal, and immorality…the exchange of the earthly body to the glorified body…the peacocks shed their feathers yearly, the new ones, more brilliant than the old…their flesh does not decay…the symbol of Christ, an all-seeing God.

We discussed whether Jane’s father committed suicide…the consensus; he gave up on life, drinking himself to death. Did Jane take her own life…she got all her ducks in order, so most likely she was tired of living alone too. We talked of the difference in Grace’s coloring versus the rest of the family and Sylvester and Ida’s “darkness of spirit,” and how she came to resent “their marriage contract.” Looking at the institution of marriage – the Chisolms, Dr. and Mrs. Thompson, Grace, and even Elijah – every character was let down by the business of love.

The true story of the author’s great aunt, on which this novel is based, has been in his subconscious since he was a boy when the mysterious “Aunt Jane” appeared in his life. He had always heard that something was “wrong” with her…she couldn’t have a “romantic” life. Mr. Watson stumbled onto a box of old photographs many years later of a pretty girl looking back over her shoulder at the photographer with a flirtatious expression and pose. It was his great-aunt – the one with the “problem.” This began a journey that ended with this book…beginning with an epigraph from Gustave Flaubert…. “She’d had, like everyone else, her love story.”
                                        On the Business side:
Cherry, Pat, and Patty are working on our Books in Bloom table (Dallas Cowboy theme) and will let the rest of us know what to bring to add to the décor. March 31st. $40.00 per person includes lunch. I would be happy to check with the organizers to see if there is any individual seating available if anyone else is interested in going to this event
                                        COLOR CODING SYSTEM
                                        WHITE:         LIGHT READ
                                        PINK:             MODERATELY CHALLENGING
                                        RED:              CHALLENGING
March 14th:                              The All Girl Filling Station’s Last Reunion 
                                                 by Fannie Flagg
                                                WHITE
Reviewer: Barbara Creach
                                                Home of Bonnie Magee

April 11th:                                The Girl Who Wrote In Silk, by Kelli Estes, debut
                                                PINK
                                                The protagonist discovers an elaborately stitched piece of fabric hidden in her deceased aunt’s island estate revealing a connection with a young Chinese girl mysteriously driven from her home a century before.
Reviewer: Pat Faherty
                                                Home of Rokhshie Malone

May 2nd                                   Earlier date due to travel conflict
                                                Orphan # 8 by Kim van Alkemade
                                                RED
                                                Reviewer: Patty Evans
                                                Wine & Cheese evening meeting
Home of Melanie Prebis.
                                                Bonnie Magee, Food Czar

Miss Jane is a “divine beacon of love that unfolds like a country creek that moves slowly on the surface but runs deep…a peaceful page-turner.”
(FYI…we talked about the “readability statistics”… the above sentence contains 26 words, one sentence. Flesch Reading Ease - 60.0 (ideal is between 60-70) and Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level, 11.3 – (ideal is below 10th grade level)

Happy Reading,

JoDee

Saturday, January 14, 2017

JANUARY 2017 BOOKERS MINUTES & MUSINGS, The Water is Wide by Pat Conroy

The eighteen children in his “charge” were “imprisoned by the circumstances of their birth.” He left them a prayer, “That the river is good to them in crossing.”

17 Bookers including one guest, Roz Ball (our resident pilot’s stepmother) visiting from Seattle, met at the home of Donna Walter to discuss this month’s selection, The Water is Wide, a memoir by Pat Conroy. Many thanks to everyone who participated in our “Bookers got you covered” hat parade in honor of Jane Freer and special appreciation to Cherry Fugitt for birthing the idea and taking charge of the program. To all who brought enough hats, scarfs, and turbans to keep our dear friend’s head warm and chic, we are grateful beyond words to be part of this special community. The hatboxes and gift sacks were delivered to their front porch this afternoon so we’re hoping this outpouring of love was enough to put a smile on Jane’s face! Many of us have projects near and dear to our hearts and as a promise to the Freers, Patty Evans pledged Wreaths Across America would continue with donations of wreaths and volunteers from the PWC and our community to deliver them with Jane leading the pack of volunteers next December. Patty will be compiling a list so if you are interested in participating in this heartfelt project, please contact her at pevans@thirdring.net. We all also extend our thoughts and prayers to those within our community dealing with on-going health issues.

Pat Conroy is the author of six novels and five non-fiction books and for those who do not know Conroy's heartbreaking work, he grew up as a military brat, one of seven children, son of a Marine Corps pilot whose hobby and solace was to beat his wife and children until they cried "uncle." He sought refuge in books partially because he knew his father would not beat him while he was reading as he assumed he was studying. Books were his constant companions as they relocated from one military base to another. The first novel his mother read to him was Gone With The Wind – and in her warm Southern tone, she took the book characters and compared them to their real-life relatives. Conroy said his mother showed him that the relationship between life and art was very close; you just had to pay attention to find it. The most powerful words in English are "Tell me a story… words that are intimately related to the complexity of history, the origins of language, the continuity of the species, the taproot of our humanity, our singularity, and art itself.” He was a poet who wrote prose….a novelist who could bring a sunset into a dark room, invite you to smell the scent of a gardenia with a few sensual words….and make you laugh and cry in the same sentence. He remains in the hearts of his fans through his words, but sentences like, “Poets candle the pilot light where language hides from itself” died with 70 year old Pat Conroy last March.

Beverly Dossett, the book’s reviewer, introduced the author (who we had to tear away from the literary laps of those legends who preceded him!) in the flesh of John Magee who took off his Chris Cleave hat and replaced it with Mr. Conroy’s. He provided a brief background of his life and an overview of his year teaching eighteen black children divorced from society living on an isolated island off the coast of South Carolina. His job as the “white schoolteacher” was to educate his students but instead they taught him….to look at life through a different lens. “They changed my life and I feel this book, The Water is Wide, was my first real book…like a firstborn child.” A few of the students crossed the water safely as one became a teacher, another, a nurse, a Gullah cookbook writer, and one worked as the assistant manager of a local Publix grocery store.

Gullahs are descendants of enslaved Africans whose origins lie along the coasts of South Carolina and Georgia and the adjacent Sea Islands such as Daufuskie Island (aka Yamacraw in the book.) They can be traced to the transatlantic slave trade of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Settlers in America struggled to find a crop that would produce sufficient revenue for England discovering rice was best suited for the coastal climate and the Africans from Sierra Leone were “imported” to farm this new crop. White plantation owners succumbed to Malaria and yellow fever leaving a handful of white managers and trusted Africans known as drivers to tend to the rice crop, resulting in a black majority in the colony by 1708. Because the slaves derived from diverse regions, they developed a creole-type language in order to communicate. Their religion, based on Christianity practiced by their white masters, differs as their faith includes communal prayer, song and dance….plus witchcraft.

The Water is Wide, written in 1972, is honored by the National Education Association – a “must read for new and veteran teachers. Conroy writes of a universal theme, young idealistic man sets out to change the world and runs into a brick wall. His teaching job of elementary age black children on a lonely outpost between Savannah and Hilton Head forced him to step outside the box. Giving out textbooks and administering spelling tests was not going to work with this group. The majority of the children didn’t know what country they lived in, could not recite the alphabet or read or write, thought the Civil War was fought between the Germans and Japanese, had never heard of an ocean much less know that it was the Atlantic Ocean that lapped onto their beaches every day, or could add simple numbers. The septic days of segregation were easy…the black schools where the sons and daughters of cotton pickers were herded together, ruled by black principals who played their role with downcast eyes. Pat knew there “was a river rising flooding the marshes and threatening dry land”…the established black/white divide was disappearing at least from an educational standpoint. His challenge, to find a level of communication with these children to allow them to see a world outside of their walls….to encourage a desire to leave the nest and to give them what was necessary to take that first step. The book, filled with humor, descriptive language, and a cast of characters so over the top if this was a work of fiction, they would be unbelievable. There is no telling what impact Pat could have had if he had not been fired after one year, but the literary world benefitted from a failed teaching career.

We discussed the Dallas Morning News article offering lessons to Texas educators and leaders on the success Singapore has enjoyed because of their dedication to teaching as a profession on the same level and pay scale as an engineer. Their top students fare as well as those in Texas but the difference surfaces with the average student. Singapore, roughly the size of Austin and a developing world country in the 1960’s, now has a higher living standard than ours; require their students to be linguistically and literally bilingual, and their teachers are regarded in an elite industry. Teacher applicants have to be in the top third of their high school class to apply and only seventy per year are accepted out of thousands. They endure extensive training and “quality control” type evaluations before trusted to educate the children and only answer to one government entity in charge of education. Pat Conroy agreed with their theory – “a true quality teacher loves the students coming to you each year.” Bookers shared personal experiences as teachers, students, and parents recognizing that a teacher’s passion often suffocates inside bureaucratic red tape and the chain of disillusionment and frustration surfaces in poor teaching and burnout….and everyone suffers.  
                                    On the Business side:

MN’s other book club, the Dauphin Island Book Club, held their first meeting in January to discuss A Man Called Ove. Eleven attended for the review by MN and live sister-prop, Pam, posing as Sonja in a wheelchair with a stuffed cat on her lap. Her group’s comments, “It’s going to be impossible to follow that.” The legend lives on!

We discussed a possible book for our March selection, Orphan # 8, a historical novel inspired by true events by Kim van Alkemade. MN has read it and highly recommends it. I’m about 25% through and will save my recommendation until I’m finished….soon I hope. So far, I love it. The story is of a woman who must choose between revenge and mercy when she encounters the doctor who subjected her to dangerous medical experiments in a New York City Jewish orphanage years before. There is a thread of a lesbian relationship throughout the book, but it is subtle. We also discussed selecting one of Fannie Flagg’s books, The All-Girl Filling Station’s Last Reunion.

Bookers has supported Henderson County Library’s fundraiser each year. The 5th annual Books in Bloom event will be held March 31, 2017 at First United Methodist Church, 225 Lovers Lane, Athens, Texas. The speaker is New York Times bestselling, award-winning historian Sam C. Gwynne author of the incredible story of how Hal Mumme and Mike Leach—two unknown coaches who revolutionized American football in the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s—changed the way the game is played at every level, from high school to the NFL. The Perfect Pass is a perfect book about football—and the transformative power of innovation. Sam Gwynne brings the same remarkable reporting and storytelling skills he used in Empire of the Summer Moon and Rebel Yell, revealing the dramatic history behind the passing revolution that disrupted and forever changed America’s favorite sport changing it from a run-dominated sport to a pass-dominated sport.

We didn’t know if this was going to be something Bookers would be interested in this year but who knew….the volunteer hands flew up…(crept might be a better word) and Patty Evans, Pat Faherty and Cherry Fugitt have agreed to spearhead the event and are already planning the table decorations. THANK YOU so much as we love this event. The tickets are $40.00 per person and it is imperative we reserve a table for 8 early so if you are interested, please email me by January 20. If we have more interest, we can acquire some additional seats at another table. When I get your commitment, I’ll write one check and you can reimburse me.
                                              COLOR CODING SYSTEM
                                              WHITE:         LIGHT READ
                                              PINK:             MODERATELY CHALLENGING
                                              RED:              CHALLENGING
February 14th:                          Miss Jane by Brad Watson, set in rural Mississippi early 20th century and inspired by his aunt’s true story.
                                                DEEP PINK
                                                Reviewer: Jean Alexander
                                                Home of Pat Faherty
March 14th:                              Book TBD
Reviewer: Patty Evans
                                                Home of Jean Alexander
April 11th:                                The Girl Who Wrote In Silk, by Kelli Estes, debut
                                                PINK
                                                The protagonist discovers an elaborately stitched piece of fabric hidden in her deceased aunt’s island estate revealing a connection with a young Chinese girl mysteriously driven from her home a century before.
Reviewer: Pat Faherty
                                                Home of Rokhshie Malone
May 2nd                                   Earlier date due to travel conflict
                                                Book- TBD
                                                Reviewer: Barbara Creach
                                                Wine & Cheese evening meeting at the home of Melanie Prebis.
Happy Reading,
JoDee

Sunday, December 11, 2016

DECEMBER 2016 BOOKERS MINUTES & MUSINGS, 7 Women by Eric Metaxas

             “Be the light that flies not from darkness, but ever towards it.”

27 Bookers and one guest, Chuck Turner’s daughter, Amy Anderssen, enjoyed a special evening at the Club in celebration of our commitment to books, friends, and the joy of the holidays. Many thanks to Courtney Dickens for loaning us her centerpieces from the Christmas party, to Tim for his generosity in allowing us a private event, and to the staff of Pinnacle for a delicious meal. This may become an annual Bookers event as lots of positive vibes swirled around the room!
We are pleased to report that Jane Freer has undergone one round of chemotherapy without any symptoms other than feeling tired. She will begin another round on Monday and as always, our thoughts and prayers continue to swell for her continued progress. She appreciates the outpouring of love from the community! Also, we will be thinking of Kay Robinson and Chuck as he undergoes bladder surgery this week.

MN and I continue to search for Bookers’ books and so far, after many disappointments, we are still reading, eliminating, and hoping for a diamond in the rough discovery to fill out our calendar. As always, your suggestions are encouraged and welcomed. We only ask that you’ve read the selection before recommending it.

Eric Metaxas is a bestselling author, the host of a nationally syndicated radio program, and a senior fellow and lecturer at large at King’s College in New York where he lives with his wife and daughter. It is a rare talent when a male voice can capture the essence of women, but he was able to bypass the Venus/Mars benchmark and tell us the story of these seven remarkable females. This book is not about feminism…but an exploration of the common thread present in each of them, detailing how they were able to accomplish great things because they were women, not in spite of being a woman. Each one changed the world. Each story championed how education lifts people out of hopelessness and criminality because education removes the gulf between the rich and poor.

Many thanks and appreciation to first-time reviewer, Rebecca Brisendine, for her analysis of 7 Women. Our purpose in selecting this book was to enlighten, and to learn and appreciate the sacrifices these women endured in the name of benevolent goodwill toward humanity. Granted faith played a significant role in their resolve, and discussion of religion is uncomfortable for some, however, Rebecca guided us through the stories with temperance and insight into the secrets of what 
made these great women greater. Well done Rebecca!

Joan of Arc: Frances Bacon said of her, “God hangs the greatest weights upon the smallest wires.”

Susanna Wesley: Home-schooled before home schooling was cool. She persevered and believed she had an obligation to the community to raise responsible children.

Hannah More: Her words swayed public opinion. She set out to make goodness fashionable.

Saint Maria of Paris: Her life, a welter of contradiction, a mother to everyone, who saw past conventional thinking that faith can only be demonstrated inside the walls of a church.

Corrie Ten Boom: She trusted in a time when the smart thing to do was to trust no one. She never believed she was as spiritual as her sister was, as patient as her father was, or as smart as her brother, but because she was chosen to spread their message, she was all of that and more. Her belief that healing was linked to forgiveness allowed her to forgive her tormentors.

Rosa Parks: She was a simple woman who believed the Bible had a social mandate in its teachings – stand up for your rights. Educated by all white teachers, she learned she was a person of dignity and should not set her sights lower because she was black. She did not give up her seat on the bus that day because she was tired…she was tired of giving up. She’s a treasure to everyone who fights for equality of the human race.

Mother Teresa: Small in stature, a giant in faith, leading people to ask, “How does such moral authority and holiness come out of such a small person?” Pope Francis at her canonization ceremony answered that, “Let us carry her smile in our hearts and give it to those whom we meet along the journey, especially those who suffer.”
                                    COLOR CODING SYSTEM
                                    WHITE:         LIGHT READ
                                     PINK:             MODERATELY CHALLENGING
                                     RED:              CHALLENGING
January 10th:                          The Water is Wide, a memoir by Pat Conroy set in the 1960’s on an island off the coast of South Carolina. He was a teacher before he became a world-renowned author and this, his first book, narrates his experience as the only teacher on the island – his students, 18 black uneducated middle schoolers, some who can’t read or write or tell you what country they live in.
                                                PINK
                                                Reviewer: Beverly Dossett
                                                Home of Donna Walter
February 14th:                        Miss Jane by Brad Watson, set in rural Mississippi early 20th century and inspired by his aunt’s true story.
                                                DEEP PINK
                                                Reviewer: Jean Alexander
                                                Home of Pat Faherty
March 14th:                             Book TBD
Reviewer: Patty Evans
                                                Home of Jean Alexander
April 11th:                               The Girl Who Wrote In Silk, by Kelli Estes, debut
                                                PINK
                                                The protagonist discovers an elaborately stitched piece of fabric hidden in her deceased aunt’s island estate revealing a connection with a young Chinese girl mysteriously driven from her home a century before.
Reviewer: Pat Faherty
                                                Home of Rokhshie Malone
May 2nd                                  Earlier date due to travel conflict
                                                Book- TBD
                                                Reviewer: Barbara Creach
                                               Wine & Cheese evening meeting at the home of Melanie Prebis.

 Who do we know today capable of changing the world?
 Merry Christmas and happy reading,
JoDee


Thursday, November 17, 2016

NOVEMBER 2016 BOOKERS MINUTES & MUSINGS, Everyone Brave is Forgiven by Chris Cleave

“He had not understood, before battle, was that time could become a ribbon to be looped and pinned back to its center, the petals of a black rosette.”

27 Bookers safely escaped an “artillery shell dropping from the sky and the wind blowing knives” as they navigated to the home of Sheri Green, a secure distance from across the pond as in 1939 Londoners prepared to defend their homeland against the Axis forces directed by Hitler’s Germany. We are delighted new member, Brenda Karnofel, was able to join us and we hope she will become a regular.

When one of our own stares into uncertainty, we most often draw on our own strength to try to right the ship for those in need. All of our PWC members and especially Bookers are flexing our muscles to help Jane Freer and her family through this trying time – knowing our wall of courage will remain unyielding until Jane is strong again. She will be seeking a second oncology opinion on Monday to map out her treatment plan. Look for additional information on their needs via our PWC update emails. The Freers were touched and thankful for our outpouring of love in our cards and basket. We can’t walk in their shoes but we can be the Doctor Scholl’s insert that cushions each step.

Patsy Dehn gave a brief synopsis of the novel, ending with “It is a stunning examination of what it means to love, lose, and remain courageous” before introducing a surprise guest who took the red-eye in from London, author, Chris Cleave, impersonated by our own John Magee, who reportedly worried about how to look British!

Patsy, assuming the role of a Barbara Walters, questioned Mr. Cleave on a variety of issues… the difficulty of following up a wildly successful book like Little Bee… the intense research required to set the details and tone for the novel… the difficulty of switching scenes between London and Malta…the reward for the reader…the timing of eliminating characters…favorite moment…what he wants the reader to take from the novel…and does he have anything in the works for his next project. Mr. Cleave-Magee did his research, giving author-like answers to each of the inquiries with conviction, humor, and expertise. Maybe John should try writing, oh, By Jove, I think he has one in the works. Thank you Patsy and John for providing such creativity to this wonderful novel…it was a tutorial on how to from one of the best storytellers!

To summarize this masterpiece any better than the New York Times would be futile. “Cleave’s foray into historical fiction is both grand and intimate. The novel’s ability to stay small and quiet against the raging tableau of war is what also makes it glorious….an absorbing account of survival, racism, classism, love and pain, and the scars left by all of them….Cleave’s prose is imbued with a Dickensian flair, deploying brilliant metaphors and crackling dialogue.” Charles Dickens loved words often including powerful adjectives to describe people and their surroundings to develop a “feel” to the piece using his rhythmic style to evoke laughter or heart-breaking sentiment. Mr. Dickens would applaud Mr. Cleave’s creativity in using a ginger cat named Julius Caesar returned from the taxidermist unstuffed to pen a letter to one of the characters.

The author wrote an antithesis to a war story. His characters didn’t become spies, forfeit everything for love, or survive a serious but non-life threatening injury while saving dozens of men only to be triumphant and live happily ever after. Cleave wrote about what it means to be brave and will that courage be sustainable in infinity. With war on the horizon each character took a leap of faith to do all the “brave” things required during a conflict – giving up civilian comforts, risking their own lives, forfeiting their place in society to help those in need, running into burning buildings to save children, and fighting the Germans. The flip side of the bravery coin is weakness and none of his cast were immune to failure posing the question, “Who knows which takes more courage – to die in battle, or to live in vain?” Is the bar set so high for bravery as to eliminate the ability to forgive smaller acts of human behavior? Each character struggled to stay alive and/or to keep hope alive in an atmosphere where morality was not a simple choice and self-forgiveness difficult to reconcile. The Oxford dictionary identifies brave as courageous but it doesn’t designate where it applies. Bravery is not listed on a job description when a person enlists or is drafted into service, but the term assumes a person was brave if he gave up his life for his country, especially during war. Sometimes the brave ones are those who survived and have to live every day trying to forgive themselves for whatever they did in the name of bravery.  

From the author’s notes, we learn the Malta siege is based on his maternal grandfather, Captain Hill of the Royal Artillery, who was assigned to mind the brilliant but overindulged son, Randolph Churchill, of the British Prime Minister. Cleave intended to write the novel by exploring the “power” dynamic between these two men, but as happens with best-laid plans he focused on his grandfather’s story in the character of Alistair. Mary North is inspired by both grandmothers to carry on a love affair separated by war “you must have enormous faith in life and in each other.” He says talking with his grandmothers about the war gave the impression, “it had been brief, uncomfortable, and not worth wasting breath on.”

The novel, well received within the majority of our group, did meet some resistance as it was described as dull, slow-moving, especially in the beginning with a love relationship between Mary and Tom that did not resonate with the reader. We discussed the impulsive actions of Mary and Alistair signing up to be part of the war effort as soon as war was declared; our opinions of the main characters; Zachery and Mary’s relationship; why Alistair couldn’t “weave himself into the new way” that London was moving after he returned; Mary’s thoughts on her “new freedoms” during the war; Mary and her mother’s relationship and the “sadness” Mary saw in her eyes; how everyone reacted during the first air raid; how Mary didn’t want London “put back the way we found it”; the significance of the jar of blackberry jam; where there moments of happiness in the novel; Hilda and Mary’s relationship; Mary’s reaction after seeing the minstrel show; and what drives the reluctance for service personnel who served during wartime to discuss their experiences. 

We talked about the significance of the ending, which found Hilda and Mary waiting for Alistair at the Ritz. Mary and Alistair’s love affair wasn’t “slow with increments of dancing and dinner.” It consisted of an air raid and a farewell at the train station. Their reconciliation began with small talk as they each questioned whether love was real or were they actors on stage following a carefully written script. She was a teacher nobody needed, a daughter who embarrassed her parents, protected in her “nest” and only an “imprint in London clay, of inherited money and looks.” He stood up to the enemy while she was proud of standing up to her mother. Their cultures were colliding, but as they sat on the floor of the Tate museum, “daylight blinded her and she blinked until the world was restored….It was an unscrewing of tarnished brass plaques. It was one tile lost to the pattern. It was an air one might still breathe, if everyone forgiven was brave.” There was a chance for their relationship.

We ended with a hope for the future, “making forgiveness possible at a national level instead of only achievable between courageous individuals.” As Patsy quoted, “Choose peace – forgive to live.”

                                        COLOR CODING SYSTEM
                                        WHITE:       LIGHT READ
                                         PINK:          MODERATELY CHALLENGING
                                         RED:            CHALLENGING
December 7th:                          WEDNESDAY NIGHT @ The Pinnacle Club. We’ll celebrate the holidays in our decorated clubhouse with a plated dinner. Details to follow.
                                                Seven Women by Eric Metaxas, inspirational biographies of what makes women great dwelling on a common thread of how these incredible women accomplished greatness because they are women, not in spite of being a woman.
                                                PINK
                                                Reviewer: Rebecca Brisendine
January 10th:                            Book TBD – Soon to be announced  
                                                Reviewer: TBD
Home of Donna Walter
February 14th:                          Miss Jane by Brad Watson, set in rural Mississippi early 20th century and inspired by his aunt’s true story.
                                                DEEP PINK
                                                Reviewer: Jean Alexander
                                                Home of Pat Faherty
March 14th:                              Book TBD
Reviewer: Patty Evans
                                                Home of Jean Alexander
April 11th:                                The Girl Who Wrote In Silk, by Kelli Estes, debut
                                                PINK
                                                The protagonist discovers an elaborately stitched piece of fabric hidden in her deceased aunt’s island estate revealing a connection with a young Chinese girl mysteriously driven from her home a century before.
Reviewer: Pat Faherty
                                                Home of Rokhshie Malone
May 2nd                                   Earlier date due to travel conflict
                                                Book- TBD
                                                Reviewer: Barbara Creach
                                                Wine & Cheese evening meeting at the home of Melanie Prebis.
The job of a novelist is to dig one small hole that must host a great number of men.”
Happy Reading,

JoDee